A Good First Step … Wednesday Cup O’Chiefs
The NFL owners took the necessary first step on Tuesday when they approved a change in overtime rules for post-season games.
Here’s to hoping they take the necessary second step and approve the change for all games, not just the playoffs. They’ll have that chance at the next league meetings, coming up in May in Dallas.
Under the new rule, if the team winning the overtime coin toss goes down on its first possession and kicks a FG, the other team would get a possession, with a chance to tie the game with a field goal or win it with a touchdown. A field goal would put the game under the old sudden-death rules where the next team to score wins the game.
The measure passed 28-4, a cushion of four votes; it needed 24 of the 32 teams to vote yes. Baltimore, Buffalo, Cincinnati and Minnesota voted against the change.
Reports from the meetings in Orlando seem to indicate there were quite a few teams that were of the same mind as Chiefs chairman Clark Hunt – why not institute the change for regular season games as well. But the owners decided to put that off until May.
”There was a lot of sentiment in the room to change this rule also for the regular season,” said Atlanta Falcons president Rich McKay, co-chairman of the league’s competition committee. ”The idea was to go back and study it . . . and then come back in May or next year or whenever it may be because there is an idea that this system needs to be changed.”
In fact, the discussion on the change was so positive and accepted by the vast majority of the clubs the vote was moved up a day; originally it was supposed to be voted on Wednesday morning. Nobody seemed to be willing to explain why the timing of the vote was changed. But there’s a good chance that the league office types knew they would lose votes if owners spent the next dozen-plus hours talking to their coaches and some general managers. Overall, the majority of coaches were against the change.
The coaches may be able to rally support against the change for the regular season in the coming months, but the rule should be standard for all NFL games.
In the last decade, the Chiefs played 10 overtime games, going 3-7. In four of those games the opponent won the toss and went down and kicked the game winning FG, with the Chiefs never getting their hands on the ball.
Eight of those 10 games were ultimately decided by a field goal. There were only two games decided by a touchdown. The first came in 2003 when the Chiefs beat the Packers at Lambeau on a 51-yard TD pass from QB Trent Green to WR Eddie Kennison. The other game came last year at Arrowhead, when Dallas earned the victory thanks to a TD pass from QB Tony Romo to WR Miles Austin.
Date |
W/L | Score | Opponent |
Won Toss |
Opportunities |
9/10/2000 |
L |
14-17 | @ Tennessee |
TEN |
FG on 1st possession |
12/16/2001 |
W |
26-23 | Denver |
DEN |
Both teams had 2 possessions |
9/22/2002 |
L |
38-41 | @ New England |
NE |
FG on 1st possession |
10/20/2002 |
L |
34-37 | Denver |
DEN |
FG on 2nd possession |
10/12/2003 |
W |
40-34 | @ Green Bay |
KC |
TD on 2nd possession |
12/3/2006 |
L |
28-31 | @ Cleveland |
KC |
FG on 1st possession |
12/30/2007 |
L |
10-13 | @ N.Y. Jets |
NYJ |
FG on 1st possession |
11/2/2008 |
L |
27-30 | Tampa Bay |
TB |
FG on 1st possession |
10/11/2009 |
L |
20-26 | Dallas |
KC |
TD on 2nd possession |
11/22/2009 |
W |
27-24 | Pittsburgh |
PIT |
FG on 1st possession |
The Chiefs have played 29 regular-season overtime games since the extra period was voted in before the 1974 season. A dozen times the Chiefs have won the OT coin toss, but only once did they go down and score the winning points on the first possession of overtime. That came in 1983, when they beat the Houston Oilers 13-10 on Nick Lowery FG.
Seven of those 29 games were decided on a field goal in the first offensive possession. The Chiefs were 1-6 in those games.
The owners need to make sure that they take the next step in May and make the rules change good for the regular season as well.
THE AFC COACHES HAVE SOMETHING TO SAY
One of the highlights of the annual March meeting is the opportunity to speak with the head coaches in attendance. Tuesday morning that meant having breakfast with the AFC coaches, all 16 of them in the same room.
That group included Chiefs head man Todd Haley. Most of what he had to say to the media in Orlando we’ve heard before from Haley. So we’ll give you comments on a couple of his new players, starting with RB Thomas Jones.
“Thomas first of all came in and really blew us all away just with his attitude and his commitment and love for the game and desire to keep playing and playing at a high level and to be part of something special,” Haley said. “He had been a couple of different places where it turned around and he liked that feeling. He wanted to be a part of it here. We’re all just really excited to get him on to the team and get him in the building. I know he’s excited about getting going. I’m a big believer in letting these guys play and compete and that was a big part of getting Thomas in here was to bring the level of competition to what maybe we didn’t have.”
And Haley talked about the addition of veteran Casey Wiegmann.
“He’s a tough, tough player, a tough, tough guy,” said Haley. “He’s played a lot of games in the league with very few interruptions. He’s a guy that a handful of us had familiarity with going back to New York. We were in New York a short time starting out when I was in personnel, for whatever reason you get connections with certain players and throughout the years when we played either Kansas City or Denver, places where Casey’s been, we’d see each other before or after the game. I’ve always been impressed with what he’s done since he left New York. When we studied Casey, it appeared he was still playing at a high level. He’s done a great job of taking care of his body, a really, really great job and he’s got the mindset that he wants to play some more.”
Haley also added some revealing comments about his young first-round defensive linemen Glenn Dorsey and Tyson Jackson.
“Obviously, we need to get better talent-wise and scheme-wise because we weren’t good enough last year,” said Haley. “There was a lot of speculation about whether he fit, are we trading him? We were clearly a better team when Glenn Dorsey played. He learned a lot of things last year and he’s much further along and now understands what our expectation level is with him and we understand him. Tyson and those guys are just night and day in talking to them having a year under their belt. It’s a difficult transition. Those guys are thinking the right way. They’re working hard.”
Here are some other noteworthy comments from AFC head coaches:
JETS COACH REX RYAN EXCITED ABOUT HIS NEW CB: “Antonio Cromartie might have as much talent as any player I’ve been around playing cornerback. Combine him with Darrelle Revis and that will be a pretty lethal combination. It allows us to not just roll coverage to one cornerback or the other, and we had to do that a lot last year. He’s got some maturing to do. Is he perfect? Probably not.”
COLTS COACH JIM CALDWELL ON HAVING A NEW OFFENSIVE COORDINATOR FOR QB PEYTON MANNING: “I’m not certain why you would try to take a guy who’s been on the rise statistically in every single category, MVP of last year and just keeps going in the right direction, why in the world would you want to change it? Every year we look at different ways to get a little bit better. But that’s one of the things that I think is dangerous. You have to be careful. You want to stay with your core values. I think that’s extremely important. But you don’t want to get stale. It will catch up with you quickly.”
BILLS COACH CHAN GAILEY ON FLORIDA QB TIM TEBOW: “He’s got every intangible that you could ever want in a quarterback. The bottom line on him is, is his delivery going to keep him from being able to play? How much work is there to be done? I haven’t gotten the tape yet, so I don’t know about his workout. But how much work is there yet to be done and how much of a change can he make. If you go with the delivery he had he will really struggle in this league.”
BRONCOS COACH JOSH MCDANIELS ON HIS SITUATION AT QB WITH KYLE ORTON AND RECENTLY ACQUIRED BRADY QUINN: “He’s (Orton) a guy who made the most of an opportunity he was given last year. He still hasn’t been in our system for a calendar year. Year 2, I anticipate he will know more, he’ll be more comfortable in a system. Kyle started all but one game for us last year, and he’s got the respect of his teammates and coaches and we look forward to him improving. Now Brady’s here competing, and as always, players determine their roles by what they do on the field.”
RAIDERS COACH TOM CABLE ON WHAT’S EXPECTED FROM NEW OFFENSIVE COORDINATOR HUE JACKSON: “Score more points. It’s plain and simple. With him, it’s not just one guy. He’s got to get 11 guys on the same page and moving in the right direction. We need to score at least two touchdowns and a couple field goals a game. If we can do that, if we can get better play at quarterback, we’ll be fine.”
UPDATING PERSONNEL: THE OFF-SEASON DAY #19
- BENGALS – RFA LB Rashad Jeanty signed tender offer.
- EAGLES – the Saints did not match the offer sheet given to RB Mike Bell. It’s a 1-year deal, $1.7 million, $500,000 guaranteed.
- JETS – RFA OT Wayne Hunter signed tender offer.
- RAIDERS – RFA LB Ricky Brown signed tender offer.
- REDSKINS – signed P Josh Bidwell.
re: said Haley. “There was a lot of speculation about whether he fit, are we trading him? We were clearly a better team when Glenn Dorsey played
Coach speak for: “Knock our doors down with a decent trade offer and we can do some bid-ness”.
I don’t think Dorsey is going anywhere. DJ could be another matter. But, I’m anxious to see what kind of a difference Crennell will make with some of these guys.
ThunderChief, I think you’re right, however I think they’re indifferent as to what happens. Either way, we’re going to get better production out of Dorsey than we have had if he remains. If he doesn’t, we have an opportunity to get a guy that more fits Haley’s & Pioli’s profile as a player.
“We were clearly a better team when Glenn Dorsey played.”
First this clearly means that we didn’t have any depth behind Dorsey. Alex Magee showed very little last year.
It wasn’t a vote of confidence either. Dorsey doesn’t fit the mold of a 3-4 DE and hasn’t displayed much commitment to improving (Came in way over weight last year). Tough guy to figure out. It will be interesting to see if Romeo can scheme around him or as Mad Chief said…move him.
Well, I look at it like this…Dorsey is just going into his third year. He’s had two different DC’s in his first two years…and neither was worth much, imo. And a D-line coach that wasn’t worth much, either…again, just my opinion. I still see Dorsey as having a lot of potential to improve his skills, and be a good player. I’m really anxious to see what some good coaching will do for this kid.
DJ? Meh. I’m hopeful that Crennel can make a difference. But after five full years in the league, I afraid we’ve seen what kind of player DJ is…a guy who shows “flashes” and big play ability at times, but is also out of position a lot and free-lancing out on the field. Not a Haley/Pioli type of player…and that’s why he rode the bench most of the time. So if someone makes a decent offer for him, I think they would pull the trigger immediately. Thing is, I’m not sure anyone will.
If we draft a quality starting NT. These are my predictions.
Dorsey will have a pro bowl year in a Chiefs uniform. DJ will find his place with this team, thanks to Romeo. Tamba Hali becomes a menace to QB society. Studebaker finds his playing time increasing as the season goes by.
Finally… our rush defense is top 10 in the league. OK guys, you can cast your stones now.
Go Chiefs.
“The owners need to make sure that they take the next step in May and make the rules change good for the regular season as well.”
Boo…this rule change SUCKs A$$. The best games of all time have been Sudden Death OT. The game that made Lamar Hunt want to be a profootball owner and led to the formation of the AFL was “the Greatest Game” (1958 NFL title game).
The longest game in NFL history (Chiefs-Dolphins 1971 Divisional Playoff game) was one of the all-time great games, as well.
And why would something that the vast majority of coaches are against be a good thing?
Pull your head out BOB…ana all of you clowns that think this rinky-dink BS is a good idea.
This blows!
Anon,
Have a set and put your name down instead on anonymous. ha jk
anyway, nfl.com has a poll, with 96,603 votes, 73% of voters are in favor of the change.
Looks like your the minority on this one dude
Mad Chief, looks like you could lump DJ and Bowe in the same sentence, potential and flashes and big play. May not be Haley type of player. Just saying may be the same guy on either sided of the ball.
el cid,
I see the point you’re trying to make. But, I have to disagree. Surprised? Ha!
Despite the drops, Bowe was 5 yards shy of 1,000 receiving yards his first year…and was over 1,000 in his second year. Yes, this past year he was disappointing. But, in his first two years…having near or over 1k yards is about all you could expect from a WR. I think we’ll see what Bowe is “made of” this season. But to be honest? I can see it going either way. I think he can be a dominating WR in this league. The biggest thing holding him back (in my mind) is…does he WANT to be?
The rationale used to garner support for the rule change was flawed. What I saw reported was 58% of overtime games were won by the team which won the coin toss. However, less than 40% of the time the team which won the coin toss won the game on the first drive of OT with the other team never possessing the ball. So, over 60% of the time the team starting on defense in overtime forced a punt or a turnover. This seems like the perception of the problem was bigger than the actual problem.
This is just another diversion by the league away from the real issues that should be resolved: installation of a slotting system for rookies — no massive contracts just because you’re a QB drafted #1 overall and won in college (the NFL is much, much different); dont’ schedule the site of the SuperBowl until after the playoffs start (no team should play the SB in their home stadium).